A Different Kind of Blog

news and things sacred and irreverent put together by opinionated people.

American Journalist Charged with Espionage by Iran Court

Posted by dorian on April 19, 2009

US ‘deeply disappointed’ as Iran convicts reporter

AP – FILE – This undated file photo provided Tuesday, March 3, 2009 by the National Press Photographers Association …
By ALI AKBAR DAREINI, Associated Press Writer Ali Akbar Dareini, Associated Press Writer

TEHRAN, Iran – Iran convicted an American journalist of spying for the United States and sentenced her to eight years in prison, her lawyer said Saturday, complicating the Obama administration’s efforts to break a 30-year-old diplomatic deadlock with Tehran.

The White House said President Barack Obama was “deeply disappointed” by the conviction, while the journalist’s father told a radio station his daughter was tricked into making incriminating statements by officials who told her they would free her if she did.

It was the first time Iran has found an American journalist guilty of espionage — a crime that can carry the death penalty.

Roxana Saberi, a 31-year-old dual American-Iranian citizen, was arrested in late January and initially accused of working without press credentials. But earlier this month, an Iranian judge leveled a far more serious allegation, charging her with spying for the United States.

The Fargo, North Dakota native had been living in Iran for six years and had worked as a freelance reporter for several news organizations including National Public Radio and the British Broadcasting Corp.

The journalist’s Iranian-born father, Reza Saberi, told NPR that his daughter was convicted Wednesday, two days after she appeared before an Iranian court in an unusually swift one-day closed-door trial. The court waited until Saturday to announce its decision to the lawyers, he said.

Saberi’s father is in Iran but was not allowed into the courtroom to see his daughter, who he described as “quite depressed.” He said she denied the incriminating statements she made when she realized she had been tricked but “apparently in the case they didn’t consider her denial.”

Saberi’s lawyer, Abdolsamad Khorramshahi, told The Associated Press he would “definitely appeal the verdict.”

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said the United States was working with Swiss diplomats in Iran to get details about the court’s decision and to ensure Saberi’s well-being. She said in a statement the United States will “vigorously raise our concerns” with the Iranian government.

The United States has called the charges against Saberi baseless, and the State Department said Thursday that Iran would gain U.S. good will if it “responded in a positive way” to the case.

Obama has said he wants to engage Iran in talks on its nuclear program and other issues — a departure from the tough talk of the Bush administration.

Iran has been mostly lukewarm to the overtures, but Iran’s hard-line president gave the clearest signal yet on Wednesday that the Islamic Republic was also willing to start a new relationship with Washington.

In a speech, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Iran was preparing new proposals aimed at breaking an impasse with the West over its nuclear program.

But Iran’s judiciary is dominated by hard-liners, who some analysts say are trying to derail efforts to improve U.S.-Iran relations.

The United States severed diplomatic relations with Iran after its 1979 Islamic revolution and takeover of the U.S. Embassy in Tehran. Relations deteriorated further under the former President George W. Bush, who labeled Iran as part of the so-called “Axis of Evil” along with Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and North Korea.

Saberi’s conviction comes about two months ahead of key presidential elections in June that are pitting hard-liners against reformists who support better relations with the United States. Ahmadinejad is seeking re-election, but the hard-liner’s popularity has waned as Iran’s economy struggles with high-inflation and unemployment.

Some conservative Iranian lawmakers played down Saberi’s conviction, saying the verdict would not affect any ongoing efforts to build trust between the United States and Iran.

“Although there is a wall of mistrust between Iran and the United States, the judicial verdict won’t affect possible future talks between the two countries. The verdict is based on evidence,” said lawmaker Hosseini Sobhaninia.

Saberi’s father disagreed, telling NPR, “I don’t think they have any evidence and I haven’t heard any evidence that they have made public.”

Human rights groups have repeatedly criticized Iran for arresting journalists and suppressing freedom of speech. The government has arrested several Iranian-Americans in the past few years, citing alleged attempts to overthrow its Islamic government through what it calls a “soft revolution.” But they were never put on trial and were eventually released from prison.

“The Saberi case is the latest example of how Iranian authorities arbitrarily use spying charges to arrest journalists and tighten the gag on free expression,” said Paris-based Reporters Without Borders.

Meanwhile, NPR said it was “deeply distressed by this harsh and unwarranted sentence.”

Iran has released few details about the charges against Saberi. Iranian officials initially said she had been arrested for working in the Islamic Republic without press credentials, and she had told her father in a phone conversation that she was arrested after buying a bottle of wine.

An Iranian investigative judge involved in the case later told state TV that Saberi with passing classified information to U.S. intelligence services.

Her parents, who traveled to Iran from their home in Fargo in a bid to help win their daughter’s release, could not be reached by the AP for comment on Saturday.

Saberi’s father has said his daughter, who was Miss North Dakota in 1997, had been working on a book about the culture and people of Iran, and hoped to finish it and return to the United States this year.


Associated Press Writer James MacPherson in Bismarck, North Dakota contributed to this report.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

here we have news from iran that is in contrast with the positive results of iran president ahmadinejad and president obama’s meeting. if there is truth to this and other news sources’ speculation that the judicial system in iran may be controlled by factions not amenable to good u.s – iran relations then ms. saberi may be an unfortunate pawn in this situation. the fact that evidence against her is being witheld to the public is cause for concern. if the iranian court does not disclose the evidences that led to her conviction then there may be reason to believe that there is credence to the speculation of a set-up. ~ dorian


2 Responses to “American Journalist Charged with Espionage by Iran Court”

  1. […] Original post by dorian9 […]


  2. Enkill_Eridos said

    Dorian and Kay beat me to the current events but I have posted a debate topic, and I address this situation in it. That being said I am going to say my opinion in this matter. This situation is being used. It will be used by our own government as well as the Iranian government. Iran is a theological democracy. The supreme leader overrides the elected leader. From my understanding of Islam women cannot hold any kind of influence in society as they are seen as lesser creatures. This journalist must have had some girls and women looking to her as a role model. Husbands and Fathers did not like this and so they trump the charges to use her as an example and keep the women in the populace from trying to emulate her. Deportation would not be enough but a conviction would serve its purpose. The punishment for espionage is death and as the low view of women in Islam that punishment would have stuck. But that would have created an unfavorable international incident. As she is not just a citizen of Iran she is also an American citizen as well, Dual Citizenship is the only thing that kept her head on her shoulders. We shall see what happens more than likely since this was a show of force to the people of Iran a behind doors comprimise will probably happen. It is a shame but it is the way of life in this world. Strange times we live in.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: